Blog Post

49ers crush Seahawks, lose Trey Lance: Good, bad, and ugly from dominant Week 2 win

Jesse Reed • September 19, 2022

The San Francisco 49ers improved to 1-1 with a 27-7 victory over the Seattle Seahawks in Week 2 but lost Trey Lance for the season.

Sunday's victory for the San Francisco 49ers over the Seattle Seahawks was nothing if not bittersweet. A dominant performance in every sense, the 27-7 win was overshadowed by the season-ending ankle injury of young quarterback Trey Lance.


In a single moment, the team's trajectory changed course. Many fans are wondering if the 49ers won the battle but lost the war. This was supposed to be THE season when the offense exploded. With Lance out of commission, it's Jimmy Garoppolo time once again for the 49ers.


Here's a look at the good, bad, and ugly from Sunday's big win.


The Good: 49ers defense has that 2019 look once again


Ahead of Monday night's two games, no team in the NFL has allowed fewer yards than the 49ers. The past two weeks, Nick Bosa, Talanoa Hufanga and Co. have been a destructive force unmatched by any squad in the league.


During San Francisco's dominant Week 2 victory, the Seahawks' offense may as well have been in a padded room wearing a strait-jacket.


The Seahawks managed to eke out 2.6 yards per carry, gaining 36 total yards on the ground. Geno Smith had a bad time out there, too. He was hit nine times, sacked twice (both times by Nick Bosa), and picked off once. The 49ers forced three turnovers in the game, picking off two passes and recovering one fumble.

San Francisco features All-Pro-caliber players at all three levels of its defense. The defensive line is perhaps the most talented and deepest unit in all of football. Fred Warner leads a linebacking corps that arguably is the best in the league. When Jimmie Ward comes back, the 49ers will have five legit studs in the secondary.


Here's how utterly dominant this defense has been through two weeks: Take away the 71 yards on the two busted-coverage passing touchdowns in Chicago, and the 49ers are allowing an insane 3.81 yards per play (385 yards on 101 plays).


Granted, this has all come at the expense of the Chicago Bears and Seahawks -- teams nobody expects to dominate offensively in 2022. That being said, there is no doubt that this defense has a championship feel once again.


The Bad: Major setback for the development of Trey Lance


This one is rough. Trey Lance, for all his talent, smarts, natural leadership, and maturity, is still one of the biggest mysteries in the entire league. The 49ers were banking on him to develop throughout this season so that, by the time the playoffs arrived, he'd have just enough seasoning and experience under his belt to handle that gauntlet.


Instead, the 22-year-old quarterback is once again back on the shelf after suffering a season-ending ankle injury on a running play that looked doomed from the start.


WARNING: Video not for the feint of heart

The worst part about the injury to Lance is that he needs as many reps as possible to develop into an NFL-caliber quarterback. By the time he starts again next season, he'll have started just six games since 2019. That's a heck of a lot of nothing for the better part of four years.


At this point, nobody really knows whether Lance can live up to his potential. We've all seen the sparkling examples of it, but in the NFL consistency is king. It's just awful for him, and the 49ers, that we'll all have to wait another year to see if he can do it.

The Ugly: Trey Lance injury brings out the worst in fans and media


Predictably, anger and sadness has permeated the team's fan base in the wake of Lance's season-ending injury. If you've spent any amount of time on Twitter since the moment he was hurt, you know people are jumping to all sorts of conclusions.


People are legitimately calling for Kyle Shanahan to be fired.

Yeah, it's bad


Some in the media are all too happy to fan the flames of rage by taking vicious potshots at Kyle Shanahan and Garoppolo, who has struggled in the past when it mattered most in the postseason. Others are practically giddy that Lance won't be under center.

This is not the kind of behavior that helps anyone.


It's understandable that fans are going to be upset. Hell, I'M upset. Totally gutted for Lance. And I'm utterly disappointed that I have to wait at least one more year to see what he's capable of accomplishing at this level.


But this is football we're talking about here, folks. Lance could have suffered a season-ending injury on a sack. He could have torn his ACL on a non-contact play. A thousand things could have happened to ultimately lead to this same result.


Does Shanahan deserve criticism for the way he utilized Lance? That's a fair question.


Readers of this site know I wanted to see Lance open up the game by controlling the ball through the air. So, I was disappointed that he only threw the ball three times in the two drives before his injury.


However, I personally think it's counterproductive to go blame-hunting. And while it's awesome that the 49ers have a fan base that is so passionate about their team, it was not pretty to see all the fighting online. Especially when we're really talking about a young kid whose career was just set back in a major way.


Let's get back to what really matters. These are people. They are all doing everything in their power to win games. It's a brutal sport, and players suffer season-ending injuries every single week in this league.


Block out the media folks who want to make a buck off your anger. What I want to see is this: Let's all look ahead to Week 3, get behind Jimmy G, and root for our team without throwing stones.

By Jesse Reed November 11, 2022
What if Trey Lance was healthy enough to play come January. Could the San Francisco 49ers bring back their young star for the Super Bowl chase?
By Jesse Reed October 31, 2022
The San Francisco 49ers are set up for a second-half run after a convincing 31-14 victory over their hated rival, the Los Angeles Rams.
By Jesse Reed October 28, 2022
The San Francisco 49ers are trending down after two straight losses. It's time for their stars to shine in Week 8.
By Jesse Reed October 27, 2022
Coming off two straight losses, the 3-4 San Francisco 49ers absolutely must win Sunday against their hated rival, the Los Angeles Rams.
By Jesse Reed October 24, 2022
The San Francisco 49ers boasted the best defense in the NFL. Then, the Kansas City Chiefs treated it like a cute little plaything during Sunday's blowout win at Levi's Stadium
By Jesse Reed October 22, 2022
John Lynch and Kyle Shanahan pulled off a stunning trade for star Christian McCaffrey, making the San Francisco 49ers a true Super Bowl or bust squad
By Jesse Reed October 10, 2022
An impressive 37-15 victory over Carolina moved the San Francisco 49ers into sole possession of first place in the NFC West. But the win did not come without significant cost
By Jesse Reed October 6, 2022
The San Francisco 49ers are vastly superior to the Carolina Panthers, but nothing is guaranteed in the NFL. Here's what they need to do in order to secure a road win on Sunday
By Jesse Reed October 4, 2022
The San Francisco 49ers are in first place in the NFC West four games into the 2022 NFL season. It's time for some grades.
By Jesse Reed September 29, 2022
It's time for Kyle Shanahan to transform this 49ers offense into a bulldozer reminiscent of the 2000 Baltimore Ravens
Show More
Share by: